Skip navigation
Contact No's - ROI 048 3755 1260  NI   028 3755 1260


Scottish Government energy policy is flawed

by JACK PONTON AND JOHN WILLIAMS DASH for wind has left us facing a power supply crisis as generation is not balanced by demand, say Jack Ponton and John Williams. There is a developing crisis in Scotland’s electricity supply, created by the policies of successive UK governments but exacerbated by the Scottish Government. At times there will be a shortage which could lead to power cuts. At others, there will be an excess which cannot be used. This is a consequence of the huge increase in intermittent wind-generated electricity. Subsidies make wind power the logical investment...

Scotland faces energy crisis by 2020

Dash for Scottish renewables is creating an “economic cuckoo” which threatens security of Scotland’s energy supplies. Scientific Alliance Scotland has welcomed a report written by Professor Jack Ponton of the Alliance and John Williams, Chairman of the Borders Network of Conservation Groups, which claims that by 2020 Scotland will be generating a huge surplus of heavily subsidised renewable electricity which it can neither use, sell nor store.  The report, published in the energy sector’s Scottish Energy News, states that the costs of producing this surplus...

Britain’s energy policy went from weird to bizarre

THE answer to Britain’s power supply is beneath our feet, writes Stuart Young. There has been much discussion recently about the unintended consequences of certain decisions, actions, or lack of action, regarding UK energy policy. Last autumn extensive media attention was devoted to the possibility of power cuts. That prompted me to look at the sequence of events leading to a once great nation not having a reliable electricity generation and distribution system. I found a number of unexpected and perhaps unpredictable consequences, but I also found a number of unexpected and...

Time to sort the facts from the fiction on GM crops

There has been some correspondence back and forth in this newspaper recently about the thorny issue of GM crops. There has been some correspondence back and forth in this newspaper recently about the thorny issue of GM crops. Genetic modification became a commercial reality in the mid-1990s and, since then, few topics seem to have generated so much misinformation and mud-slinging. The scientific evidence is clear; GM crops currently approved are as safe as any other variety of the same crop. Attempts to "prove" otherwise are a clear example of anti-science bias, with...

Examination of WWF Scotland’s Claims for Wind Generation

Conducted by Stuart Young in collaboration with Dr George M Lindsay.

Renewables drain our resources

ENVIRONMENTAL advantages of renewable energy are a myth – fusion energy is the way forward says Anthony Trewavas Renewables use sun, water, wind; energy sources that won’t run out. Non-renewables come from things like gas, coal and uranium that one day will. But unless electricity and motorised transport are abandoned altogether, all “renewables” need huge areas of land or sea and require raw materials that are drilled, transported, mined, bulldozed and these will run out. Wind turbine towers are constructed from steel manufactured in a blast furnace from mined...

Relying on wind power won’t be miracle solution

What is this other source to be, if not nuclear, says Jack Ponton The Holyrood parliament does not have formal responsibility for energy policy in Scotland. However, it does have control of general planning. Further, the owners of Scotland’s conventional electricity generation capacity have currently no incentive to expand it. These factors have enabled Holyrood effectively to take control of all new energy developments. This has already resulted in the construction or consent of renewable capacity to meet the more than 96 per cent of the SNP’s 2020 target of the “...

That mankind is changing the climate is commonly accepted

The claim is supported by increasing greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions from fossil-fuel burning, a global temperature increase from 1975-1998 and future temperature projections derived from climate models. The Kyoto protocol based on model projections aims to keep future temperature elevations below 2ÚC by severe reductions (decarbonisation) in GHG emissions, and fossil-fuelled electricity generation is considered a primary emitter. But the alternatives, so-called renewables, are very expensive and area-hungry. Biofuels from cereals have actually increased world food prices; wood has...

In the News

Read recent news related to Scotland surrounding the themes of Our Planet, Our Resources and Our Technology.

Farming in harmony with wildlife

Intensive production methods have skewed agriculture’s connection with nature and that must be reversed, says Edward Baxter The Land Reform Review Group’s proposals for radical change in the ownership of land in Scotland published at the end of May this year are of no small consequence. Two years in the gestation and fraught with much politicking, their report included a proposal for the absolute right to buy for some agricultural tenants, those few thousand individuals holding secure ’91 Act tenancies. The upshot of this proposal will be an argument about the capital...

Current Issues

To see UK electricity demand
and the contribution from
wind, see


What's New

The Scientific Alliance has published a new report on wind energy, jointly with the Adam Smith Insitute:  Wind Power Reassessed: A review of the UK wind resource for electricity generation.